Introduction
0:13
Are we good? Evening, I'm Andy Hill, Superintendent of Schools. I'm Doug Beeman, Treasurer of Wadsworth Schools. We are here tonight to answer questions that you may have relating to the one percent earned income tax initiative for a period of five years that will be on the ballot here in November. So are you ready, Doug? Yep. You want to start with the first question? Sure. So the first question that we had came in prior to this evening. How much would the district save without the routing software that shows parents when the bus is coming? Would that save any jobs? Yeah, so we have a program called BusRight that we use.
Would dropping the bus-tracking software save money?
0:44
Unlike our previous program that we had, which was called Transfinder, where you could add different modules. Our understanding with BusRight is it's one cost for the entire program. So the feature for parents to be able to see buses is part of it. We mainly use the program to actually be able to do and create the bus routes. The program itself is forty nine thousand four hundred dollars for the year. But if the question is eliminating the ability for parents to see the buses, we do not believe there would be any savings there. Because we would still need to have the routing software. Otherwise, that would probably cost us more money to do that manually in terms of hiring people, right? Correct. Yeah, correct. The next question we had was, what about community fundraisers? so I think we're uh we're not quite sure how that question was what it was posed to mean I think we are if it's are we doing Community fundraisers the answer is the school district has a lot of fundraisers that happen but if it's probably more aligned with what about Community fundraisers to replace the one percent earned income tax five-year initiative Do you want to comment on that?
Could community fundraisers replace the levy?
1:40
Yeah, so the proposed levy is projected, and these numbers come from the Ohio Department of Taxation, since if the levy were to be successful, they would be the one collecting those tax dollars for us through the filing of your state income tax. So they provide the estimates to us, and it's projected to generate about eight point eight million dollars annually. So that would be quite a bit of fundraising. Yeah, I don't know that that would be a fair ask to be able to do, nor sustainable, quite honestly, for what is needed for the school district. So, Doug, I think this is one that, if you don't mind, you can take. If the work outside of Wadsworth What do I need to do with my employer to make sure I pay the income tax correctly?
I work outside Wadsworth. How do I pay this correctly?
2:58
So as I started to mention on the previous question, the school district income tax is part of your state income tax return. So it's not filed like a local municipal income tax. Currently here in Wadsworth they use RITA. It would not be filed as part of your RITA return or your city income tax. It's filed as part of your state income tax return. If your employer elects or wants to do a courtesy withholding for you, they might do that now if you work outside of Wadsworth for the City of Wadsworth income tax. They could do that. Your employer would not have to, but larger employers, I would guess, probably would. Smaller employers may not. But you would work with your employer to see if they'd want to do that courtesy withholding. If not, then you would simply include that like you would regardless on your state income tax return, and you would have to pay it at that time when you pay the rest of your state income taxes when you file. Depending on your situation, you may be required to do quarterly payments if that's not being withheld, but those are all certain things that you can work through with a tax professional or with the Ohio Department of Taxation. Their website's pretty robust and has a lot of information. Thank you. So our next two questions kind of are similar. I think we'll read them both for the purpose of what we're doing here. But I think the answer ties together probably for both of these as we talk through it.
Why isn't there a specific list of cuts, and why did cuts wait until September?
4:32
So why do other districts have a clear plan of what will be cut if their levy fails? But we just have concepts of a plan. And we knew the levy didn't pass back in May. Why did we wait to discuss cuts until a September special board meeting? This is exactly what the community means by a lack of transparency. Can you admit you dropped the ball and waited too late? So you want to start? You want me to start? I would say, so I don't believe that we waited. So after the levy failed in May, we started making reductions right away to the tune of four and a half million dollars in reductions that were made to start the twenty-six, twenty-seven school year. So once the levy failed in May, we had a plan in place going into that levy. It was part of our precaution plan that we were required to file with the Ohio Department of Education and Workforce. That plan laid out the number of positions that would need to be reduced because we had to show a positive balance in fiscal year twenty-eight and we did that. We could not show a negative balance in that year that we were just heading into. So we did that as part of our plan of reductions and those were all done going into this school year and now we're starting to talk about the reductions that would be made if we're not successful again in November. So it's been part of that plan going back to the Ohio Department of Education and Workforce that were implemented for this school year, four and a half million dollars, um, twenty six teaching positions in our fourteen to fifteen support staff positions and administrative position, um, and multiple non employee reductions that were also reduced heading into this year so we did make a lot of reductions after the levy failed and now we're starting to talk about what is the next round of levy reductions that wouldn't happen until august of twenty twenty seven to the twenty seven twenty eight school year yeah i think that's a big part of it where you just ended there doug yeah and um We're looking at it. So the board has not talked about doing mid school year reductions, just like just like last year. And so we've positioned ourselves into looking at then planning for what would have to happen prior to the start of the twenty seven, twenty eight school year if additional revenue is not secured. When the board looks then at what are those areas, what we have to look at is what does the state minimally require that we operate and do? And where then do we spend dollars that exceeds state minimums? So the board since last spring has been engaged in surveying. They did a future planning survey in April. They did a follow-up survey that was closed last month. on some of those questions and some additional areas. They've identified areas, reduction in workforce, larger class sizes, fewer programs, course offerings, potential loss of the neighborhood elementary school model, maybe even through closure of a school less support for wellness, reduced student transportation, extracurricular impact, whether that's a reduction in what's offered and or an increase in fees that's greater than what they already increased for the current school year, a reduction to state minimum for kindergarten, which are half-day programs. So they've identified those, but there's a lot of details that have to be worked through there, Doug, to be able to figure out what all those would look like and you know i would suggest that for most people if the board sat down in a two-hour meeting and decided to name every position that was going to be cut and name a school that would close that there'd be an outcry of people rightfully so because there wasn't an opportunity for more meaningful engagement and dialogue along the way so you know the board is the board is working within these areas that have been there they'll continue to work there. And if we have to get to a point where reductions have to be made for next school year, that'll happen in a manner that's timely for that school year. So like of those areas, like transportation, there's a lot of levels there. Right. Like break down like some of the different decisions that can be made, like for us to say that we're going to state minimum transportation. Well, there's a lot of area between what we currently do now and state minimum. So it may not be all the way to state minimum. It could be somewhere in the middle and a lot of other things with scheduling and planning and start and stop times of buildings are all impacted by those. Yeah, that's absolutely true, Doug. So, you know, in our current fiscal precaution plan, the part that has not been implemented yet was to reduce transportation to state minimum. And so state minimum transportation is students in kindergarten through eighth grade that live more than two miles from their assigned school and students at the high school level from Wadsworth High School to their career tech program and back to the high school. Currently, we transport and have for years students that reside one mile or more from their assigned school kindergarten through twelfth grade. So as we look at this and We're looking not only at what kind of potential savings could be there if we went to state minimums, but we're looking at what if we increased the walk zone radius to a mile and a half instead of a mile, but still kept it K-twelve. What if we increased it to two miles, but kept it K-twelve? And there are definitely implications, like if we were to reduce to some level, to get these routes to then balance, we may have to shift and adjust the start time of some buildings to be able to do that. Something else that people may not realize about transportation The law says more recent in the last few years was put in. Once you start the school year, we cannot reduce in a negative way the type of transportation students started with at the beginning of the year. So in the area of transportation, as an example, the board doesn't have a choice but to wait till the start of the next school year. So there's so there's so many different implications on this that The board is doing their due diligence to work through this, we feel like we've identified both through the surveying through the numerous board meetings were discussions have happened through the infographic that was released on Friday. We have an idea now of where all of that stuff would impact. Now it's just the details. If we have to, if we have to get there, we're not trying to keep anything from the community. You know, we can always do a better job with how we communicate. But if somebody wants to be able to go watch the discussions that are happening, real time meetings are recorded. There's board meeting minutes that are included with the next board meeting agenda that goes out from the one before. We have all kinds of information on the website. When we push out messages, it's going to literally tens, ten to fifteen thousand unique email addresses, social media sites. So we're not trying to withhold information. We're trying to provide it so that people can make an informed decision on this one percent earned income for five year initiative. because that's our job, is to make sure information's there, make sure it's available, and make sure that we get it to people so that they can then make whatever their informed decision is when they cast their ballot. So on your screen, we're looking at an infographic that says what's on the line. And that's something that's been available on Facebook and on our district website that encourage people, if they haven't seen it, to make sure they do that because it will walk you through those things that could potentially be reduced if we aren't successful. I think another one that has a lot to unpack is the idea of closing a building and the ramifications if we do that. It seems like a no-brainer with our declining enrollment. And more importantly, not only declining enrollment, but the number of reductions that we made this year. So we reduced fourteen sections. So that's fourteen less classes, fourteen less teachers in K through fourth grade this year. So our five primary elementary buildings are, which would allow us to then close a building moving forward as enrollment continues to decline if it does. But there's also ramifications with what's going on in our community with construction of new homes. and how long we can hold a building if we close it and it's not being occupied. So I think that's important. Like a lot of people say, I almost like that's a no brainer. You can save some money there, probably upwards of a half a million dollars if you close that building. But there's there's other costs associated with that in the future if we have expansion. Yeah. And when Doug talks about what you can do with a closed building, the state legislature and governor have signed or enacted things in the law That not only define what's considered to be an unused school facility and the definition is a little different than what you may think. And, and then what we then have to do with that, if it sits empty for an extended period of time, that's defined in the law. So the board needs to look at the, you know, we keep hearing about the. Home units that are being built with all of the different development in town. And while we haven't seen it with other developments that have gone up lately, we have to be prepared with those come students. So it's not to say that the board won't decide that what that step is with the school needs to happen, but there's a lot of dialogue that they need to work through. And again, we're working on a timeline for the start of the twenty seven, twenty eight school year. So I see a question came through about one percent five years and a little bit of information about what we're asking for and maybe how that differs from what it was in May when it was one and a half percent for continuing period time. And I know one question to build on that that I've received is like, how is that even possible? Did we ask for too much in the spring and why are we why are we asking for less now? And I think the big answer to that is we heard the community You know, we listen to the community saying one and a half percent continuing is too much and we don't like the continuing part.
Why ask 1% now when May was 1.5%?
15:15
So how do we bring it to a half to down to the one percent? Again, we reduced four and a half million dollars annually out of the budget. Twenty six teachers and administrator, numerous support staff and about a million dollars worth of non personnel reductions that are taken out of our budget. That's the difference between one and a half and one percent and why we're able to do that now. So when we were asking for one and a half, I don't think we were asking for the moon. We were asking to continue services at the level that we were offering them now. We have a new level of service, higher class sizes, less items for kids that are being offered now, Chromebook replacement, whatever it might be that was reduced. which is why we were able to go down to the one percent to maintain services at the new baseline level moving forward, and also heard the community that they did not like the continuing portion of that levy too, so the board didn't like to put this one on for a five-year period, and then it can be reevaluated at the end of the five years. Yeah. And you know, when one of the changes that happened this year with those fourteen sections that you talked about at the elementary level, Doug, is that we had to move students out of their already established home based geographic region schools. So we had forty five students that ended up being that had to be reassigned to a different school for this school year, which is different than what typically happens here. And so there's already been kind of some of them, the erosion of the neighborhood school model. And as we look at this stuff, it's hard. Like what we did in the spring to get to the four and a half million to implement for this school year was hard. And it made changes that people feel. But we were able to do it in a way with increasing class sizes and some of the elementary stuff I just spoke about. And then the fees where we were able to preserve most programs and services for kids. I think we're at a point now as the board has these discussions, as you look at the areas that are being focused on to be able to make the level of reductions that are gonna be needed if additional revenue isn't secured it's going to have to be programs and services that are going to be impacted in ways moving forward.
Who actually pays an earned income tax?
18:05
I think another question looks like it just came in was around who pays for the tax. So earned income versus a traditional income and who might be responsible for that. So with an earned income tax, it is just people that are receiving W-2, 1099 type income. So pensions. Social Security, interest income, dividend income, those types of taxes, those types of income are not part of what you would pay the one percent tax on. So your people that are on a fixed income, we hear that a lot with property taxes. with our elderly population that are on a fixed income and that own their homes. Now they're being forced to pay more and more taxes on their home, and it isn't fair. So that's the nice thing about the earned income is it does not impact those types of people unless they have true W-2 or 1099 earned income. It is also only people that reside in the Wadsworth City School District. So if you would vote on this levy, then you would pay the tax. If you live outside of Wadsworth and work in Wadsworth, it's a little bit different than a municipal income tax where you would pay that if you work here. If you work here but don't live here, you would not pay it. So if you vote on it, you pay for it. And then again, it's just on the earned income. So those other types of income that you might get through other means would not be subject to the one percent earned income tax.
Is there a list of businesses that support the levy?
19:32
So we're asked to remind you again that you can submit questions through the website or on the website. We have a question here about, as a community member, I support businesses out at First Friday who support the levy. How can I find a list of those? So as a school district, we do not have any such list of what's being asked for. Our job and what we're permitted to be able to do is provide factual information People would just simply say, when we go back to that second question that was asked about community fundraisers, we are very fortunate that there's so much support for our schools within the community, especially the business community.
What was done in earlier years to control costs?
20:22
But we don't have a list like that. Doug, anything you want to add there? A question came in regarding cuts or looking ahead to get to this point several years ago. Yeah. So the question has to do with cuts and looking ahead to get to this point several years ago. We have been we have been working through mostly attrition to be able to make changes. um over the course of time where we could make reductions to kind of right-size staffing to the number of students that we've had we've eliminated programs along the way where there wasn't student interest and a lot of the stuff that we've initiated through board action to provide additional supports, programs, services to students have been through the strategic planning process and implementation of that. Yeah, I think it's just another way to say that as our enrollment's been declining, we have been reducing staff. So if you look back at the number of staff we've had over the course of the last five years, each year we've reduced staff. Some years that was a net because we were also bringing the new Grizzly Academy online. And we can talk a little bit about that as well, how that's saving the district a lot of money. So some years we were adding Grizzly Academy staff, but in our core classes, K through twelve, we were eliminating or reducing staff, primarily as teachers resigned, we would move teachers around or retired and fill those positions as needed, recognizing that our enrollment was declining and we needed less staff in order to carry out the mission of the school district.
What is the Grizzly Academy and what does it save?
22:05
Let's talk while we're on that for a moment. The Grizzly Academy. So we're in the fourth year of our Grizzly Academy, which, if you're not familiar with it, is an alternative school for students that need a different type of setting to be for services for school. We were paying a lot of money to send students out of our district. And that's hard for students, for families. And financially, it was a lot to be sending to different schools and programs. So our Office of Student Services, some others pitched the idea of creating our own alternative school and our board approved that and we phased it in. So the first year we were kindergarten through fourth grade, the second year through fifth grade. Last year and this year, we're now through twelfth grade when we look at what we would have otherwise spent if we sent the students that are at grizzly academy to the schools, they would have went to before grizzly academy existed. Look at transportation and then we subtract out every cost for grizzly academy. This past year, we were to the positive of? Eight hundred thousand dollars. In savings. Yeah. So it's been a great thing for kids to be able to stay in Wadsworth City Schools. It allows us to be able to transition students back and forth as needed with the desire to always be to have students in their least restrictive environment. And then financially, it's been a good savings for us as well. And as the name states, we're keeping them here being Grizzlies as opposed to sending them to Medina or Rittman or wherever else we were sending students to be educated. So why did we select an income tax this time compared So question is, why did we select an income tax this time as opposed to a property tax? Yeah, I think a lot of reasons went into the board's decision on income tax versus property tax. The primary ones being that if you look at property tax rates in the state of Ohio, there are only seven states in our union that have a higher property tax rate than Ohio.
Why an income tax instead of a property tax?
24:10
Additionally, there's only seven states in the union that have a lower income tax. So we are a very high property tax state and a very low income tax state. I think that's proven by the initiative that was attempted to be put on the ballot to eliminate property taxes in totality in the state. You can see that through the number of bills that have been introduced and passed in the last two years on property tax reform. Property taxes are high, driven primarily by increased home values and what have you, but also driven by what I talked about before, that low income tax. If the state's lowering the income tax from nine income tax brackets to one, That means the state's bringing in less money. If the state's bringing in less money, that means they have less money to give to public education. If we get less money from the state for public education, we have one choice, property tax. We have two choices, property tax or income tax. Most school districts go with a property tax, which is why we have one of the highest property tax rates in the union. So while the state has been trying to bring that back through reform, think they need to reflect a little bit and say why do we have high property taxes and I think it's a lot of it has to do with the income tax rate so our Board of Education said well if we have a low income tax rate and a high property tax rate let's try and balance those out a little bit and propose an income tax that would help balance that out and provide more equitable system for our for our students So on a similar note, if the schools can function or could function on a smaller one point zero tax rate now, why was it requested in May one point five?
If 1% works now, why was May's request 1.5%?
26:10
Yeah, so the question is, if the schools are able to function on a smaller one percent earned income tax now, why was the initial request in May one point five percent? So we'll go back to what Doug talked about earlier. the the reason that we were able to reduce the percent of the ask is because we did change service levels for this year with over four and a half million dollars in reductions and fee increases that happened that savings on an annual basis then allowed us the board to be able to reduce the ask to one percent and then because of the feedback that was received in may even though the property taxes that are in place had all been continuous, the feedback was pretty clear that the continuous aspect with the earned income tax was problematic. And so the board chose to make it for a five-year period of time as opposed to continuous. I think it's important to note, too, also, Andy, that those reductions that were made are going to continue. So even if we're successful in November, those fourteen sections of K through four that we keep referencing or the sections at the intermediate school, middle school or high school, those aren't planning to come back. Like this levy is going to collect four million dollars less than what the one and a half percent is. So we need to sustain those four million, four and a half million dollars worth of cuts in each year moving forward. So unless enrollment or something would drive those sections, some of those sections to come back due to class size, right now the plan is every reduction that has been made for the for the twenty six, twenty seven school year is being continued into the future.
What happens to extracurricular and pay-to-participate fees?
27:55
regardless of whether we're successful in November or not. And if we're not successful in November, then that goes back to what we talked about towards the beginning of the evening with the list of possible reductions that will have to go on top of what we've already done. Can you talk a little bit about the estimates for pay-to-play or pay-to-participate and how those would affect extracurriculars and or athletes? So the question has to do with if there's any estimates on pay to participate, pay to play, how that could affect extracurriculars if we're not successful. So our Board of Education, part of what was in the initial fiscal precaution plan was to increase the fees by fifty percent. After the failure in May when the board had a series of meetings, that's what they ended up doing, was increasing the fees fifty percent, which took them, the high school level as an example, from a hundred to a hundred and fifty dollars. We had pulled information together from other places at that time and even with our fifty percent increase, we're still on the much lower side of things. We have a five hundred dollar family cap that the board left in place. so while we we don't have an estimate to throw out there we know that the board potentially would look to revisit that as an area if we need to for the next school year yeah going back to that graphic that we talked about earlier what's on the line one of those is extracurriculars and what those would look like whether it's reductions in extracurricular offerings or combination of increasing fees on the pay to participate side and that's not just athletics that's all sorts of student activities so student council and chess club at the elementary schools and speech and debate or whatever it might be all those activities are all impacted by those fees as we try and increase revenue to help offset the cost of offering those in an effort to continue to be able to offer those to our kids, because the last thing we want to do is is reduce opportunities for kids if we can get additional revenue to help keep those going, because those extracurriculars are just so critical to students, especially at the middle school and high school level. And we heard that from the board rep to the the representative student to the board at the special meeting last week. You know, we the board did ask a question on that topic. as part of that follow-up survey and I think one of the other questions that came in was those survey results so we do have a summary of those results pulled together and that'll be part of what will go out on Friday when the board meeting packet for next Monday's October meeting is released So there'll be the full set of summary of results from what we saw. But in particular on that extracurricular question, I would tell you that when asked about keeping extracurricular activity cost affordable versus taking and splitting the total cost of all extracurriculars and then figuring out what needs to be paid to offset it completely the it was like a two-to-one almost of people that supported keeping them at an affordable level but the board again we'll just have to work through that if that's if that's where we end up needing to be so property taxes where they currently are why in the increases why has that not offset the revenue loss from our declining Okay, so the question has to do with property tax and with where they're currently at, why hasn't the increases offset the revenue loss from declining enrollment?
Property values went up 25%. Why didn't school revenue?
31:20
So Doug, you want to? Yeah, so let's take a step back to twenty twenty five when Medina County had a reappraisal and many of you as property owners probably received a letter from the county auditor saying the value of your property went up. So we have this thing in Ohio called House Bill nine twenty that as property values go up the effective millage rate on a levy on any voter levy goes down. So in essence the homeowner on average pays the same for that voted tax levy today as the day it was passed even though the value of their home increased okay so as property values go up the effective millage rate goes down and you pay the same now i say on average because that's what we see as a district right we see aggregate numbers you as a homeowner if your property value went up more than the average then yeah your tax bill went up that means conversely somebody's property value went up less than the average and their tax bill actually went down again now i'm talking about voted levies Now there's a whole other side of this called inside mills, where that does not get reduced as property values. So there's ten mills in the Constitution that aren't impacted by House Bill nine twenty. So when your values go up there, your tax bill also goes up on those inside mills. But that's a fraction of the total millage. So for Wadsworth City Schools, we have five point one inside mills. we have a total of twenty-four effective mills. So it's a small portion of our revenue. So what does this all mean to Wadsworth City Schools and to you as your tax bills go up? Property values went up about twenty-five percent on average through the reappraisal in twenty-twenty-five, impacting your twenty-six tax bills. Twenty-six tax bills are paid out over two fiscal years for us, so that means over the course of two years, our property tax revenue went up about four percent. Okay, so do we see additional money from reappraisal? Yes. Do we see a twenty-five percent increase that you saw in your property values? Not even close. Again, property values went up twenty-five percent. We saw over the course of fiscal year twenty-six and twenty-seven, our current fiscal year, about a four percent increase in actual property tax collections. So we see some money, but certainly not enough of a four percent raise over a three year period, because we only have a reappraisal every three years. four percent every three years when we're not seeing increases in state aid which we haven't even got into yet tonight um we can go there next but half our about well not used to be half our revenue came from property taxes now about sixty five percent of our revenue comes from property taxes and to see a four percent increase over a three-year period just isn't bringing additional revenue to the district to offset all the things we're seeing on the expenditure side whether it's staffing health care renewals you know Fuel, like we all know what we're paying at the pump right now, right? Well, imagine that times, twenty some buses on the road every day, multiple vans on the road every day. So we feel the inflation that everybody is feeling at home with everything that we're buying, whether it's supplies in the classroom, technology. Chromebooks have gone up exponentially and we have a one to one initiative with our students and Chromebooks have gone up. So all those costs are going up, but we're not seeing increases in revenue. Minimal increases in revenue on the property tax side, and then the state aid side is a whole other conversation. Right. Pretty much stagnant. Yeah. Can you talk about educational advantages or disadvantages on class size? The question is, talk about educational advantages or disadvantages on class size.
What does class size actually change?
34:40
I think, uh, you know, when it, so, um, I don't know how detailed we want to be here, you know, like there's the study from the eighties out of Tennessee called the STAR study that talks about the, the educational benefit and impact, especially at the younger years. When you look at smaller class sizes, our board of education, It around twenty fifteen set targets for smaller class sizes at the K two level in particular, but the elementary is in general. And we were able to achieve that through a combination of how we assign students doing some tweaks with some declining enrollment. With at one point years ago, the addition of a few additional teachers, but I think if we had some of our teachers in here, they would be able to speak much more eloquently than myself or Doug can. about what that actually looks like and how much more can get done when you're working with twenty one kindergarten students and not thirty or whatever the numbers are. And so it's more personalized instruction. And I think that the research effects of smaller class sizes may wear off as you progress through the education system in a way that's been measured and shown. But I don't think anybody can dispute that when there's more people, there's less personalized instruction and experience, which can have a negative impact in certain situations on learning. So as we make those, You know, that's what we're sacrificing is a lot of the personalized instruction, a lot of the reasons that we were trying to drive down and get smaller class sizes to begin with. know and that all started by the way with the board with some discussion of parents that were had kids coming into kindergarten in the fourteen fifteen school year and shock that was expressed when they saw that we had classes that were thirty or more with with things back then um and so it you know there's reasons that we've ended up where we are and that that's what's been This whole thing like when we go back to what happened last spring, for a moment, and people are asking about cuts. The board first came to the Community and said hey if we want to keep this level of services that we've become accustomed to here's what it's going to cost and now that now that that wasn't possible. Now we've gone through and made reductions and implemented those. Those reductions are playing out real time as this school year progresses. They're not planned to come back like Doug talked about because we've now lowered the ask to hopefully be able to preserve the services and programs that are currently in place now. and um and we've lowered the request to be five years and not continuous so that there is a continual ability for people to be able to come back if needed in the future and let us know what they think of the job that's being done so has the board considered why did they not consider being a plaintiff on the vouchers for Ohio schools?
Why isn't Wadsworth a plaintiff in the voucher lawsuit?
38:55
Yeah. So the question has to do with the Board of Education. Have they considered being a plaintiff on the on the lawsuit against the use of the vouchers, the choice program dollars that the state of Ohio has? So the board has had public discussion on that comment before. And they've stayed away from joining into that right now. I think it's been a while since they've had that discussion. Do you recall any large reasons sticking out? No, I don't. Yeah. I don't either. I think it's just been something that they've chosen to steer away from. It's a controversial thing, so I think that's part of it. Yeah, and I think rather than investing dollars there, choosing to invest dollars in what is happening is happening here. I think along those lines, instead of focusing on that part of it, what we really need to focus on is what is the state doing for public education. When I say public education, I say as you and I, the people in this room, Dr. Hill and myself, think of public traditional K through twelve public education, not vouchers, not charter schools. And when you look at the change and the shift over the last ten years in that it is dramatic.
How has state funding for Ohio schools changed?
40:15
So I mentioned before in twenty sixteen we received about half our money from the state and half from property taxes. Today it's sixty seven percent from the state and less than thirty five percent from our sixty seven percent from local property taxes and less than thirty five percent from the state. There's been a dramatic shift in the way that they fund public education. Ohio is lagging behind in what the state is doing for public education. Nationally, on average, states provide about nine thousand dollars per kid to local school districts. In Ohio, it's closer to six thousand dollars per kid. In Wadsworth, it's less than five thousand dollars per kid that we get from the state of Ohio per child for educating them. If you think about that difference between five or even six thousand and the national average of nine thousand times our close to four thousand students, it's well more than the eight point eight million dollars that we are asking for here locally. We would not have a need for this levy if the state was funding us the way the rest of the states throughout our country are funding public education. And as we continue to realize that and look at that, I've been doing this for twenty-two years in Wadsworth. I've been in education for over thirty years. It hasn't changed. In nineteen ninety-seven we passed the DeRolph case that said there was an over-reliance on property taxes and here we are almost thirty years later and it's still the same thing. if we want strong local schools it's going to take strong local support it's not coming from columbus under the current administration and it's probably not going to change anytime soon we have a need to continue the services the way that we are offering them today which is different than the way we offered them last year But if we want strong local support, strong local schools, it's going to take local support. Things aren't going to change in the near future based on history related to public education. It's probably just going to get worse. That spread of how much are we getting locally versus how much are we getting from the state just continues to widen. Yeah, I was going to say, too, you know, it's well said, Doug, to the question that was asked. I read today, earlier today, because there was a letter on this topic that I received, that Wadsworth's not alone, just for what it's worth. There's about half of the public school districts in the state of Ohio that are part of the said lawsuit, and half that aren't. There's about six hundred and ten or twelve districts in the state, so a little over three hundred of them are. The discussions that our board has had, the decision to kind of stay away from that for the time being is something that half of the other school districts in the state have done as well.
You built new schools. Why can't you pay to run them?
43:25
Question about building new schools versus... keeping central. Sure. Yeah. So the question has to do with building new schools versus where we're at now financially. And they use central intermediate school as an example. We've we've been hearing a lot since the board decided to be on the ballot in May. The question that so often it's on one of our frequently asked question lists that we have. So you build it. Now you can't pay for it. and so uh what we would say to that is this you know the the first of all the community is the one that has chosen through their choice at the ballot box to support these initiatives to build new schools we can't do that without community support on any of them that have been built and then secondly when the community does support the building of schools the bond issues that pass to fund those are not something that can be transferred over to general operating fund with where this problem is. If anything, the district is actually saving dollars in our general operating fund on efficiencies with the building. Like when we think of the former intermediate schools central, the amount of money we were spending on a regular basis to try to fix things that were not fixable, to try to keep heating and air conditioning going, just utility bills alone. Those are things and areas where we're seeing savings that are actually helping our general operating bottom line. yeah i think you know in twenty twenty one the community approved that levy and those funds are earmarked to pay back those bonds just like you as a homeowner would have a mortgage that you pay back over a period of time those funds have to be used from that we understand it's all taxes to you right as a homeowner it doesn't matter if you're paying a bond issue or operating it's all taxes to you and we're we're sympathetic of that and we understand that but the community approved that in twenty twenty one that decision was made in twenty one And it has nothing to do with what we're asking for now. When that was approved in twenty-one, it was a combination bond and operating. Some of that millage went to the bond, some went to operating, similar to what we're asking for now. And at that time, we told the community that we thought that this bond issue, or excuse me, the operating portion of that levy would last about five years. That was twenty-twenty-one, it's twenty-twenty-six now. The need has nothing to do with the new school. As Andy said, if anything, it's helped us in that regard. It's important to remember that. But we also understand, like, it doesn't matter if it's bond, property, operating, whatever it is, income, it's all taxes to you. And we're sitting to understand that, but we need to understand the differences as well. Can you talk real quick, Doug, in regards to these bond issues?
What has the district done to pay off bonds early?
46:30
Can you talk about what we've done to be able to pay some of them off early? Yeah. So when we had that bond issue in twenty one, one of the things that are part of that levy was we had the bond issue from nineteen ninety seven that built Lincoln Franklin in the middle school and did renovations to the Central Intermediate School. We paid, that was a thirty year bond that got paid off two years early because we had done refinancing, similar to how you might refinance your mortgage when interest rates are low. When bond rates were low, we did several different bond refunders or refinancing of that, which allowed us to decrease millions and millions of dollars of debt service payments, interest payments over the life of those bonds that allowed us to pay them off two years sooner. So that millage rate that was being paid for those bond issues was taken off the tax duplicate two years early back in twenty twenty one. Yeah, I think the other thing and you know, this is kind of a trip down memory lane for a memory that I wasn't even here for. But I think on the topic of facilities, it's worth noting, like when we were starting to look at the intermediate school, the current central or the former central intermediate school, I reached out and had a conversation, I hope he doesn't mind me mentioning, with Chuck Parsons because I was trying to understand as we looked at things, like how did we get to where we're at with this building? Chuck told me a story from the nineties where there was a ballot initiative, a bond issue that came forward to combine, I think it was Lincoln and Franklin elementary schools into a big one. and save the district dollars and the community overwhelmingly voted it down and in chuck's words came back and told us come up with a plan that keeps a separate lincoln a separate franklin builds a middle school and renovates the old intermediate school and when they brought that back even though it cost a lot more money it passed So you know the choices that we've made that we're now here with with neighborhood schools, as an example. You know that's what our board is really trying to work through and understand like that's why it was a question on the survey in the spring and a follow up question. You know, it'd be just because it was important in the nineties when that decision was made just because it was important in two thousand nine or ten when the bond issues passed to build the three others along with the high school community center. Maybe that importance isn't the same as what it is today in two thousand twenty six. So our board's really trying to grapple with that, but in no way ever. did the Board of Education somehow magically just build schools at the community's expense without the community giving their approval? And that's the same with the most current building we have. And I think the surveys that you mentioned earlier are part of how they're trying to garner some of that information related to, you know, are neighborhood schools as important today as they were back in the nineties or even in two thousand eight when the three other elementaries were built on the neighborhood school concept. Yeah, right. I mean, it's you know, we anyways, whether more where can i go as a taxpayer where can i go to see an itemized breakdown of exactly how the school district is going to spend this you know income tax dollars spent over the So I think the best thing, if you go right to our homepage and scroll down to news stories, there's three things across the bottom.
Where can I see an itemized breakdown of the spending?
49:40
One is an infographic about the levy and some facts, but there's also the financial forecast of the general fund, as well as the related assumptions that will show you a detailed breakdown and a twenty-some page description of what those numbers come from. So it shows exactly how much money we collect from property taxes, exactly how much money we get in state aid for not only this year, the previous three years, and the future three years. And then it shows where we're spending our money on, how much we spend on wages and benefits and purchase services when we say purchase services those are things like utilities or tuition that we talked about earlier if we have to send kids out of district all those other types of services that we might bring in so like occupational therapy and physical therapy where we bring people into our buildings to provide those services to kids that all falls under that category and So it gives you a very detailed breakdown looking at the history, future, current year, and then the related assumptions can walk you through what goes into those numbers and the different aspects of it looking historically and into the future. So I would say that that's probably the best place to get a detailed picture of where this money would go because this money would all come in for operating and what we're talking about and that That document is our guiding document that the board, our administrative team, uses to make decisions about the future. Oh, go ahead. www.wadsworthschools.org. That'll take you to our home page. And if you scroll down, you'll see the news story that Doug's talking about with the financial information. like we're trying to interpret another question that came through it's okay can you talk a little bit about the middle school situation and how it was repaired the length that went into the repair and why it lagged a little bit parts yeah so the question has to do with the beginning of the school year and the middle school where the chiller was down So in, how did we get to there?
What happened with the middle school air conditioning?
51:35
In May, at the May board meeting, it may have been May eleventh, the Board of Education approved an urgent necessity resolution for a company called Geffert to purchase and install, make functional a chiller and boilers for the middle school. At that time, the current, then current chiller was still operating. We were told that There would be up to a I think it was a twelve week procurement period and then for three to four week installation period, if I'm not mistaken. And that would be worst case scenario, which would have put us right around the end of August, beginning of right around Labor Day at the worst case. In June, the then current chiller stopped working. And in August, We didn't get to say it took an extra three or four weeks for them to procure it because there was parts they were waiting on. So we were fortunate that part of the strategic planning that had been done on the capital side was to repair windows at the middle school. We're not suggesting that that in any way, shape or form substitutes for working air conditioning. But depending on where you're at in the building, uh there's a lot of air that can move through those so that's what happened we ended up we ended up with a contingency plan a few different times we moved students from the middle to both the intermediate and the high school and at the as of last week both chiller and boilers are all installed and fully fully functioning we went through went through a process there, tried to work through a lot of stuff and we go backwards with some of the decisions that were made there late August.
Where else can people hear from you?
54:30
I think we probably would look at it a little bit differently with implementing the plan to move to the other two buildings quicker. Anything else? So Doug and I are, on wednesday night this week there's a community forum presentation at weatherstone clubhouse at six thirty on thursday night there's a candidate forum that the wadsworth area chamber of commerce is putting on i believe it's six o'clock at the celestia theater wadsworth fund square foundation building And we're back here again for another one of these, October twenty second, I believe. Correct. At the same at the same at the same time in the senior center is. Hold on, I can look here. It's next week, I believe. Wednesday at two. We'll be at the Soprema Senior Center on Wednesday, October fourteenth at two p.m. So there's opportunities if if anyone is interested in learning more about it for to see a more detailed presentation and to be able to ask questions. If anybody has questions on the one percent earned income for five years, Doug and I are both happy to be able to answer questions. We're also happy to just be able to point you in the direction of where you can get the information that you need. so that you can review it yourself and then be able to make an informed decision, whatever that decision is, when you cast the ballot. So we just thank you for your time tonight. Yeah, along those lines, I would just encourage people to get the facts. There's a lot of information out there. People can put information out there. And if you're gonna make an informed decision, you need to vote how you need to vote, but make sure you know the facts and make sure you get those information, whether you do your own personal searches, reach out to any one of us, reach out to your building principals, if you have kids in school, whatever it might be, and get the information you need to make your decision. yeah so in give a number and an email three three zero three three five one three zero zero it's a direct line for me at work and a hill at wadsworthschools.org is an email and if it's a question that's better suited for doug i'll make sure that doug gets it but again thank you for your time tonight
Transcribed from the broadcast captions and corrected for names and terms the transcriber misheard. Otherwise left as spoken, false starts and all, because this is a record of the evening rather than a cleaned up version of it.